The Importance of Documenting and a Guide to Ensure Adequate Evidence

​

To systematically identify, document, and categorize potential nuisance events (fugitive dust, noise, after-hours work, speed, vibration) observed in surveillance or recorded footage related to the loss of quiet enjoyment claims.

​

​

General Guidelines for All Categories

1. Watch in Real Time – Avoid skipping unless the scene is clearly irrelevant.

2. Note Exact Time Stamps – Record start and end time (to the second if possible).

3. Describe What You See – Use neutral, factual language (e.g., “Truck passes at high speed” rather than “Dangerously speeding”).

4. Capture Context – Note weather, lighting, number of vehicles/people, and any other relevant activity.

5. Flag Repeated Offenses – Note if the same activity occurs multiple times in a shift/day.

​

• Document with exact timestamps.

• Describe neutrally and factually (avoid legal conclusions — just state what happened).

• Contextualize (e.g., wind direction, lighting, proximity to homes, time of day).

• Clip & Save the footage if possible, with category label.

​

​

​

Category Guidelines

1. Fugitive Dust

• What to Look For:

  • Visible dust clouds leaving a work area, especially blowing toward residential or public areas.

  • Material being dumped, loaded, or moved without dust suppression (e.g., no water spray).

  • Dust plumes from vehicle movement on unpaved or dirty surfaces.

• Documentation Tips:

  • Note wind direction (if visible from flags, smoke, dust movement).

  • Indicate whether dust dissipates quickly or lingers.

  • Record the apparent source (truck, loader, pile, conveyor, etc.).

2. Noise

• What to Look For:

  • Machinery operating at noticeably high volume (especially if unusual for the time of day).

  • Backup alarms, horns, or prolonged equipment idling.

  • Impact noises (e.g., banging metal, dropping loads).

• Documentation Tips:

  • If video has audio, describe the noise type, duration, and intensity (e.g., continuous, intermittent, sudden).

  • If no audio, look for visual cues like vibrating equipment, shouting, or startled reactions from people nearby.

3. After-Hours Work

• What to Look For:

  • Any activity occurring outside normal permitted hours (check the official permitted schedule).

  • Lights on and machinery/vehicles operating before start time or after stop time.

  • Deliveries, loading, or construction outside approved hours.

• Documentation Tips:

  • Always note the exact time.

  • Describe the specific work (e.g., “Front-end loader moving gravel” vs. “equipment in use”).

4. Speed

• What to Look For:

  • Vehicles moving faster than safe for the site (e.g., dust trails, bouncing loads, inability to stop quickly).

  • Passing other vehicles or unsafe maneuvering in tight spaces.

• Documentation Tips:

  • Note type of vehicle and approximate speed if possible (even “appears faster than walking pace” is useful if in pedestrian areas).

  • Mention if speed contributes to dust, noise, or safety hazards.

5. Vibration

• What to Look For:

  • Large machinery, compactors, or trucks causing visible shaking of nearby objects (e.g., fences, poles, ground).

  • Loose materials (e.g., gravel, tools) visibly moving due to vibration.

  • People reacting physically (steadying themselves, stepping back).

• Documentation Tips:

  • Identify the source of vibration.

  • Describe the intensity (e.g., “vibration caused nearby light pole to sway”).

  • Note whether vibration coincides with heavy loads, passing vehicles, or equipment use.

• 6. Light Pollution / Glare

• Why: Bright or misdirected lighting can disturb nearby residents at night, contributing to nuisance and interference claims.

• Look For:

• Floodlights shining into nearby homes or public spaces.

• Lights left on outside normal hours without necessity.

• Flickering or flashing lights from equipment.

• 7. Odors / Emissions

• Why: Visible emissions or mist from operations can support nuisance or negligence arguments.

• Look For:

• Steam, smoke, or chemical haze drifting toward homes.

• Spraying or misting activities in windy conditions without containment.

• Workers reacting to smell or coughing (if audio/video captures this).

• 8. Unsafe Operations / Hazards

• Why: Negligence can be shown if unsafe work practices are documented.

• Look For:

• Workers or equipment operating without proper safety barriers near property lines.

• Loose materials falling outside work zones.

• Equipment operating close to public sidewalks or neighboring property without separation.

• 9. Encroachment / Trespass Indicators

• Why: Physical entry or intrusion onto another’s property is direct evidence of trespass.

• Look For:

• Vehicles, workers, or equipment crossing into non-work property.

• Materials being stored or dumped outside designated site boundaries.

• Overhanging booms, cranes, or conveyors swinging into neighboring airspace.

• 10. Blocking Access / Obstruction

• Why: Preventing normal access can support nuisance or interference claims.

• Look For:

• Work vehicles blocking driveways, sidewalks, or roads for extended periods.

• Equipment staged in a way that limits pedestrian or vehicle movement.

• Debris or dirt accumulation on public pathways.

• 11. Visible Property Damage

• Why: Damage strengthens negligence and trespass claims.

• Look For:

• Cracks, dust staining, or debris on nearby buildings/fences after heavy activity.

• Falling objects from equipment or loads.

• Vibration-related damage (e.g., loosened panels, broken glass).

• 12. Public Disturbance Indicators

• Why: Shows the scale and impact of disruption beyond just noise/dust.

• Look For:

• Residents confronting workers or pointing toward site.

• People recording with phones or gesturing at site operations.

• Groups gathering in response to incident.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​